Home
News
Opinion
About
Archive
Jewish Insider
Subscribe
Facebook
Twitter
News Opinion Your Daily Phil
Facebook
Twitter
Subscribe
Search

Opinion

A Parable of Three Houses: A Guiding Principle for Engaging and Inspiring Millennials

March 6, 2015
Share
Facebook
Twitter
Email
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

3 housesThe institutions that will sustain themselves and the Jewish world at-large will be those that invite and challenge young Jews to thrust themselves into the process of building our collective house.

By Andrew Fretwell

I would like to share with you a parable inspired by “The Home We Build Together,” by Rabbi Jonathan Sacks*.

Once, there were three families who lived in separate beautiful houses, and each house had been passed down from generation to generation. The family who owned the first home hired a contractor on retainer to make repairs, as needed. The family who owned the second home made repairs on their own, but ensured efficiency on repairs by only allowing the work to happen while their children were out of the house. The family who owned the third house also made repairs on their own, but they went out of their way to include the children, even if it occasionally slowed progress.

What happened to these houses?

In the first house, the spiking of contractor’s fees combined with the family’s inability to make their own repairs resulted in the family both abandoning the house and selling the property to a developer. The second house stood until the parents passed away, when their grown children were unable to maintain it; they vacated and rented a nearby apartment, leaving the house to fall into disrepair. But, the third house stood through time; this house still flourishes today, with multiple generations regularly working together to repair and improve it.

I believe the family who owned the third house represent what we, the Jewish People, must strive to achieve. The Talmud says, “Call them not your children; call them your builders.” “Builders” is not a term we should use to only describe our teens, students and young adults; we should inspire and equip them to call, think, and act like builders. The institutions that will sustain themselves and the Jewish world at-large will be those that invite and challenge young Jews to thrust themselves into the process of building our collective house. The task is as simple as it is critical and profound: hand our teens, students and young adults a figurative tool belt, show them the cracks in the walls, and tell them, “What I have done we will now do together, and you will continue to do after I am gone.”

A few examples:

  • Camp Tel Yehudah’s Hadracha Activism Institute empowers teens to dive deeply into a number of societal issues and implement a Jewishly driven activist campaign.
  • Hillel’s Ask Big Questions poses to Jewish college students the very questions that the Jewish community has wrestled with for thousands of years.
  • Natan Fund’s Amplifier galvanizes Jews in their 20’s and 30’s to organize peer-led “giving circles” and create communities of giving through the lens of Jewish values.
  • Independent minyanim like Shir HaMaalot, a volunteer-led, Havurah that hosts musical Friday night services and a potluck dinner in Brooklyn.
  • Moishe House Without Walls imparts skills and resources to young Jewish adults to envision, create and host meaningful programs for their peers.

These are excellent models that train and empower young Jews to be builders. At NEXT, we are piloting different ways for Birthrighters to create DIY experiences in New York and San Francisco through microgrants. To my colleagues who engage millennials: how else do you inspire and equip young people to act like builders? What has worked well in your community – or for your specific initiative – that others can adapt and utilize?

We know empowerment is key and meaningful engagement is a multi-stepped process. And while we should also look beyond our own field for ideas, we now need to look to each other to make this strategic goal accessible, scalable, and sustainable.

*At the beginning of the book, “The Home We Build Together: Recreating Society,” Rabbi Jonathan Sacks uses the metaphor of three houses that all accommodate visitors and guests differently to represent nativism, multiculturalism and pluralism.

Andrew Fretwell is the New York Community Activator at NEXT: A Division of Birthright Israel Foundation. He welcomes your questions, comments and ideas at andrew.fretwell@birthrightisraelnext.org.

Your Daily Phil

July 3, 2025

Your Daily Phil: Israel’s impending mental health ‘tsunami’

News

A view of the damage is seen after a missile launched from Iran on June 15, 2025, struck the Israeli city of Bat Yam, south of Tel Aviv, on June 20, 2025.

Q&A

Brooklyn-based La’Aretz Foundation looks to give $2,500 directly to victims of Bat Yam missile attack

FIRST AID

Israeli mental health experts raise alarm of impending ‘tsunami of war-related psychiatric illness’ after 20 months of conflict

MAJOR GIFTS

Frieze Family Foundation commits $5 million to create ‘Center for Shared Society’ at University of Haifa

HIDDEN FEES

Foundation for Jewish Camp raises $2M to offset added costs to American camps from Israel-Iran war

TRANSITIONS

UJA-Federation of New York’s Eric Goldstein to step down next year

BARUCH DAYAN EMET

S. Daniel Abraham, major Democrat donor and funder of Middle East peace initiatives, dies at 100

CONNECTION INTERFERENCE

‘Mifgash’ programs struggle as trips canceled and Israeli teens barred from traveling overseas

Opinion

MIXED MESSAGES

Corporate silence in a time of war: Global corporations walking the Israel tightrope

WAKE UP CALL

Antisemitism is a warning sign. Are we listening?

SHAKE THINGS UP

Breaking the enrollment paradox: A new approach to Jewish day schools

IN THE AFTERMATH

Supporting the bereaved families left behind

SPACE TO SHARE

When teachers are learners: Making professional growth visible in Jewish education

A COMMUNITY MODEL

Elevating Jewish early childhood education means elevating how we recruit and retain educators 

Navigation
Home
News
Opinion
Archive
About
Social
Facebook
Twitter
Subscribe

Copyright © 2025 · eJewishPhilanthropy · All Rights Reserved

Subscribe now to
Your Daily Phil

The philanthropy news you need to stay up to date, delivered daily in a must-read newsletter.

Subscribe to Our Newsletters to Access

Enter your email to gain access to our exclusive content
Don’t worry, if you are already subscribed you won’t receive our newsletters twice