• Home
  • About
    • About
    • Policies
  • Submissions
    • Op-eds
    • News / Announcements
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

eJewish Philanthropy

Your Jewish Philanthropy Resource

  • News Bits
  • Jewish Education
  • Readers Forum
  • Research
  • Show Search
Hide Search
You are here: Home / Jewish Culture / Against Definition

Against Definition

May 24, 2010 By Bob Goldfarb

Recently I was talking with a colleague who asked about my organization and what we do. When I explained that we work with partner organizations to plan cultural programming, she retorted: “Define cultural programming.” This isn’t unusual. I work for the Center for Jewish Culture and Creativity, and by now I’m used to being asked to define “Jewish culture,” not to mention “Jewish music” and “Jewish literature.”

It’s not just a question of culture. Not long ago I was part of a conversation about changes in Modern Orthodoxy where one participant asked another to define “Orthodox Judaism.” The list lengthens quickly. What is tikkun olam? Who is a Jew? What is loyalty? What is anti-Semitism?

These demands for definitions appear to seek clarity, but they are really about something else. It’s not like asking someone to explain the meaning of, say, “eleemosynary,” a word whose meaning may not be familiar. Everyone knows more or less what “Jewish” and “culture” mean. Seeking an a priori definition of “Jewish culture” is actually the first step in a negotiation about boundaries, deciding what’s included and what’s kept out.

Whether it comes from an impulse for control, or from a simple bureaucratic desire for tidiness, such a negotiation is unhealthy. It replaces a flexible, intuitive, shared understanding of an idea with a category circumscribed in the abstract. It diverts energies away from producing concrete results and towards a verbal border skirmish over disputed territory. It may be tempting to debate a semantic question rather than resolve a substantive issue, but that debate adds little value.

Setting rigid boundaries is especially counterproductive in qualitative pursuits like the arts, and it is undesirable wherever barriers promote exclusion based on illusory or arbitrary differences. Yet bureaucracies often make definitions an end in themselves. Such differentiations, created largely for their own sake, take on a life of their own, and the result is to marginalize and exclude things that don’t fall within the new definitions.

Of course some distinctions are necessary. The government of the United States is obliged to delineate who is a citizen and who is not. Property owners need to know the exact boundaries of their property. The precise meanings of common terms like “resident” or “employee” need to be spelled out. Distinctions like these are a necessity in the context of contracts, finances, or the law – but not in ordinary conversation in the Jewish community.

The phrase “Jewish Peoplehood” has resurfaced lately, and predictably, one response has been to try to define it and articulate a theory and practice of the concept. If that impulse succeeds, institutions will ultimately erect barriers between what Peoplehood includes for their purposes and what it doesn’t. That would be regrettable for a number of reasons, starting with the irony of taking the word “Peoplehood” out of the hands of the very people it is meant to embrace.

This is a singular opportunity for a grass-roots process to determine what Peoplehood is all about. Rather than convening experts and conducting research to define it, why not invite the whole spectrum of interested Jewish individuals and organizations to enact what they believe Peoplehood to be. Let it take shape according to the collective experience of our many communities. If that isn’t Peoplehood, what is?

Bob Goldfarb is the president of the Center for Jewish Culture and Creativity in Los Angeles and Jerusalem. He also blogs for the Los Angeles Jewish Journal.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Jewish Culture, The Blog Tagged With: Jewish Culture, Peoplehood

Click here to Email This Post Email This Post to friends or colleagues!

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. The Loxist says

    May 29, 2010 at 1:56 am

    In South Central, the question “Where you from?” is a dangerous question that implies questions about gang affiliation and economic background. In the same way, defining one’s neighborhood and boundaries in the oh-so-Jewish quest for identity in a fragmented world is increasingly tightening the Gordian knot.

  2. Larry Kaufman says

    May 29, 2010 at 5:15 pm

    There are certainly situations where boundaries are needed. Case in point — what is Jewish art, which translates to what can be exhibited in a display space/gallery operated by a synagogue. (As president of a congregation which established a gallery, I lived this.)

    Any work created by a Jewish artist, regardless of subject matter? Any work with Jewish subject matter, regardless of artistic quality — and who determines quality? For that matter, who determines Jewishness of subject matter?

    In the congregational setting, we experienced disagreement in all of these areas among the clergy, the art professional who served as volunteer curator, the art committee, a board member who wanted his wife’s floral landscapes shown, etc.

    Hammering out a policy and predicting contingencies, etc., is arduous — but it’s a lot easier in the long run to evaluate against a policy than to consider each instance de novo.

Primary Sidebar

Join The Conversation

What's the best way to follow important issues affecting the Jewish philanthropic world? Our Daily Update keeps you on top of the latest news, trends and opinions shaping the landscape, providing an invaluable source for inspiration and learning.
Sign Up Now
For Email Marketing you can trust.

Continue The Conversation

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Recent Comments

  • Bruce Powell on An Invitation To Transparency: Reflections on an Open Salary Spreadsheet
  • Sara Rigler on Announcement: Catherine Reed named CEO of American Friends of Magen David Adom
  • Donna Burkat on The Blessings in 2020’s Losses
  • swindmueller on Where Do We Go From Here?
    Reflections On 2021
    A Jewish Response to These Uncertain Times
  • Alan Henkin on Where Do We Go From Here?
    Reflections On 2021
    A Jewish Response to These Uncertain Times

Most Read Recent Posts

  • Jewish Agency Accuses Evangelical Contractors of “Numerous Violations” but Denies They Evangelized New Immigrants
  • Breaking: Birthright Israel & Onward Israel Seek to Join Forces to Strengthen Jewish Diaspora Ties with Israel
  • An Invitation To Transparency: Reflections on an Open Salary Spreadsheet
  • Why One Zoom Class Has Generated a Following
  • The Blessings in 2020’s Losses

Categories

The Way Back Machine

Footer

What We Do

eJewish Philanthropy highlights news, resources and thought pieces on issues facing our Jewish philanthropic world in order to create dialogue and advance the conversation. Learn more.

Top 40 Philanthropy Blogs, Websites & Influencers in 2020

Copyright © 2021 · eJewish Philanthropy · All Rights Reserved