School Change – It IS Possible
By Maya Bernstein and Bryna Leider
If you believe that a changing world and a constant influx of new research about how people learn – what motivates us, what sticks with us, what helps us lead meaningful and successful lives – impels even great schools to be on a constant evolutionary journey, we have some insights to share from a recently completed three year experiment.
The brainchild of The Jewish Education Project and Upstart, and generously funded by UJA-Federation of New York, the Day School Collaboration Network (DSCN) sought to increase empathy, creativity, experimentation, collaboration, and innovation so that schools might become more agile learning organizations.
DSCN was designed as a multi-year cohort, in which participants would actively engage with the principles of Design Thinking through in-person professional learning experiences and guided practice in their respective schools. Almost immediately, this model proved effective in quickly moving participants from a theoretical understanding of Design Thinking into entirely new ways of operating in their professional and personal lives. The shift was so apparent that it inspired the Stanford d.school – the home of Design Thinking – to create a nearly identical program www.dhometeam.stanford.edu for schools in the San Francisco Bay Area.
At the outset, the question of impact of Design Thinking on specific, school-based challenges was not a jump; much experimentation had already taken place. What was less proven was whether the process could be expanded to become a tool for whole school change. As the original designer, together with Ela ben-Ur, of DSCN’s content, Maya Bernstein posited that participants would need help navigating the human dynamics, politics, and cultural fall-out of leading change and advocated for the inclusion of Adaptive Leadership in the program. Pioneered in our work at DSCN, the insights gained from the combination of the two theories have just been published in a journal article in the Stanford Social Innovation Review written by Maya Bernstein and Marty Linsky.
We have come to view the combination of Design Thinking and Adaptive Leadership as a shortcut towards whole school change, but it is not magic. Change is still slow (which is why The Jewish Education Project decided to continue the program after the funding cycle ended), but we have witnessed exquisite glimpses of what is possible. For example, the team from Magen David Yeshivah taught the design process to teachers, administrators, students and parents around the question: “What might Magen David look like in five years?” By the end of the year, every elementary staff member, six classes, and 90 parents had learned Design Thinking while becoming participatory members of the visioning process. Subsequently, the team took all of the insights and ideas gathered and again used the design cycle to determine the first action steps towards realizing the vision. View Magen David’s story as well as other stories of personal learning and shifts in institutional cultures here www.jewishedproject.org/DaySchools/Day-School-Collaboration-Network .
To learn more about the prototypes that the teams created, visit http://www.jewishedproject.org/sites/default/files/uploaded/PDF/Luria%20Teacher%20Rounds%20Protocol%20for%20website.pdf for Luria Academy’s protocol for Teacher Rounds; http://jcdsri.org/category/class-blogs/design/ for JCDS of Rhode Island’s student Design Lab; and http://www.jewishedproject.org/DaySchools/Day-School-Collaboration-Network#lamplighters) for a description of Lamplighters Yeshivah’s numerous projects.
Maya Bernstein is an Associate at UpStart, an organization that partners with innovators to redesign the experience and expression of modern Jewish life; she is the original designer of DSCN’s content and approach.
Bryna Leider is the Director of the Day School Collaboration Network at The Jewish Education Project